Make a Payment – Insurance Billing Made Simple
Convenient Insurance Payment Options
Paying your premium should be quick and easy. At Antioch Insurance, most payments are made directly through your insurance company. Below you’ll find payment phone numbers and online links for our carrier partners.
Carrier Payment Links & Phone Numbers
Safeco Insurance
Pay online or call
1-800-332-3226
Travelers Insurance
Pay online or call
1-800-252-4633
Progressive Insurance
Pay online or call
1-800-776-4737
Midwest Preferred Mutual
Pay online or call
1-800-225-5636
Grinnell Mutual
Pay online or call
1-877-467-2252
Hagerty
Pay online or call
1-877-922-9701
Nationwide
Pay online or call
1-800-421-3535
Liberty Mutual Insurance
Pay online or call
1-800-225-2467
Steadily
Pay online or call
1-888-966-1611
The Hartford
Pay online or call
1-800-243-5860
Need Help with a Payment?
Not sure how to pay, or having an issue with billing? Call us at (816) 454-0400 during business hours, and we’ll walk you through your options.
Paying Through Our Agency
While most payments go directly to your insurance company, we’re here if you need assistance. Stop by our Liberty office and we can help facilitate your payment. (Note: Specify whether Antioch accepts checks/money orders — insert here based on agency policy.)
Policy Changes and Reviews
Has your premium gone up? It may be time for a policy review. We can re-shop your coverage with multiple carriers to make sure you’re still getting the best value.