About Antioch Insurance – Family-Owned and Community-Focused

Three women hold an Antioch Insurance Agency sign, smiling inside by a window.

Our Story and Values

Antioch Insurance Agency has protected Kansas City families since 1964. Founded on values of trust, integrity, and neighborly care, we’ve remained family-owned and rooted in the community for decades.


Our mission is simple: make insurance personal, understandable, and reliable. We believe the best service starts with knowing your name, your story, and your goals — not just your policy number.

Meet Our Team

Behind every policy is a real person who cares. Our licensed agents bring years of experience, but more importantly, a dedication to treating every client like family.

Woman with glasses smiles; she's wearing a patterned shirt with greenery in the background.

Melissa Cole

Personal Lines Agent
Antioch Insurance Agency

Office Number: 816-454-0400

Fax: 816-455-1680


Melissa is an agent for personal lines. She enjoys quilting and spending time with her grandchildren.

Blonde woman smiling, wearing a light blue sweater and necklace, sitting outdoors in autumn.

Kristen Goeke, CISR

Personal Lines Agent
Antioch Insurance Agency

Office Number: 816-454-0400

Fax: 816-455-1680


Kristen began her insurance career in 2003 at Antioch Insurance Agency. Kristen holds a license in Property and Casualty Insurance and has also obtained her Certified Insurance Service Representative (CISR) designation.


Kristen enjoys spending time with her family, friends and volunteering.

Silhouette of a person with a head covering within a gray circle.

Megan Castledine

Personal Lines Agent
Antioch Insurance Agency

Office Number: 816-454-0400

Fax: 816-455-1680


Bio coming soon!

Antioch Insurance Agency

Office Number: 816-454-0400

Fax: 816-455-1680


Bradley, a graduate of University of Missouri – Kansas City with Bachelors of Business Administration- Major Accounting.


Retired from banking in 2014 after 36 years holding positions as Auditor, Commercial Loan Officer and Relationship Manager with various well-known banks in the Kansas City metro area.


2014 began working with Melissa and the staff at Antioch Insurance Agency as accountant and helping with business development Past member of Platte County EDC and Northland Regional Chamber of Commerce. Past Board member of Midwest Small Business Finance an affiliate of Clay County EDC.


Enjoy playing golf and fishing and spending time with our 5 grandchildren.

Our Partners & Carriers

As an independent agency, Antioch represents a wide range of top-rated insurance companies. This gives our clients choice, flexibility, and the confidence of knowing they’re getting competitive coverage backed by trusted carriers.


In the Community

Insurance is what we do — but community is who we are. You’ll find us supporting local schools, sponsoring youth sports, and volunteering at events like the Liberty Fall Festival.


We also connect clients with trusted local contractors, repair shops, and resources through our Resource Hub, because protecting your family often extends beyond the policy.

What Our Clients Say

Our clients say it best:

Five black stars.

Very friendly staff and easy to work with. Switched policies on auto and home while buying and selling a house. They handled everything for us!

Jason Bundy

2 months ago

Five black stars in a row, indicating a high rating.

Always appreciate the care and service that Anna provides for my mom's policies, and now mine. She listens and learns who we are and what our needs are. She is very quick and responsive, and finds us the best options.

Dave Croswhite

10 months ago

Five black stars in a row.

Anna, was great to work with when we first moved to the area. She was very responsive and professional. She helped get us the policy we needed when we closed on our home and helped with transitioning our vehicle policies.

Kimberly Combs

6 months ago

Ready to Help You

At Antioch Insurance, we’re more than your agents — we’re your neighbors and advocates. Whether you’re new to Liberty or a lifelong resident, our door is always open.